| 47 | Kenya Capers | at MACC vs. Northwest Missouri C.C. | 2/16/1994 |
| 46 | Malcolm Thomas | at MACC vs. Hannibal LaGrange | 2/14/1983 |
| 45 | Freddie McKinney | at MACC vs. Malcolm X | 2/3/1979 |
| 45 | Qyntel Woods | at Penn Valley | 11/14/2000 |
| 44 | Kenya Capers | at Eldorado vs. Frank Phillips | 11/26/1993 |
| 43 | Leroy Jackson | at Claremore, OK | 12/15/1977 |
| 42 | Charles Dudley | at MACC vs. Hannibal LeGrange | 12/17/1968 |
| 42 | Malcolm Thomas | at Hutch vs. DeKalk, GA | 3/17/1983 |
| 42 | Dwight Sistrunk | at MACC vs. Malcolm X | 1/7/1984 |
| 41 | Don Anielak | at MACC vs. Hannibal LeGrange | 1/29/1951 |
| 41 | Raynard Sills | at MACC vs. Vincennes | 1/30/1975 |
| 41 | Freddie McKinney | at MACC vs. Penn Valley | 11/17/1978 |
| 41 | Qyntel Woods | at Rolla vs West Plains | 3/9/2001 |